I don't like Westerns very much. There are so many of them, and they play incessantly on television in front of old people who live without aspirations or energy. The overwhelming quantity means there are plenty of poor ones - not badly made as such, but tediously efficient, competent, formulaic and uninspired. The aesthetic doesn't appeal (though I like the hats), and neither does casual violence against indigenous Americans, so if I need to watch a film set in the age of the Wild West (about 1865-1895), I'd generally rather it was set in Khartoum or Transvaal, to avoid such well-worn cliches and over-familiar pictures.
There are a few notable exceptions. A friend showed me Sergio Leone's Dollars Trilogy, which starts slowly and dustily, but ends with the breathtaking 'The Good, the Bad and the Ugly' (1966) which I embraced despite its genre and count as a favourite film, and I likewise find delight in 'Back to the Future Part III' (1990) and in 'Living in Harmony', the unexpected Western episode of 'The Prisoner' (1967), though the first of these three is quite unlike the genre as it stood, and the other two subvert it to make unusual points as parts of bigger plots.
|I really like the framing that's possible in the Academy ratio.|
Who needs the wild novelty of widescreen, unavoidable from the next year.
To my surprise, the film turned out to be a really good drama, with well-written, well-played characters and an interesting story, which I later learnt was a metaphor for Hollywood blacklisting. The film wasn't just a set of hollow cliches - it was genuinely atmospheric, crisply shot in handsome greys, and without the simplistic morality I've tended to associate with fifties Westerns. Crucially, it didn't have John Wayne in it, an actor who stands for all I dislike in the genre (and who, as keen McCarthyist, vocally opposed this film, deriding it as un-American).
|Grace Kelly gets the high billing, but Katy Jurado's Helen Ramírez is much more interesting.|
She seems far more honest and more in control of her destiny than most in the town,
and almost the only person to leave the film with their credibility intact.
High Noon and The Good, the Bad and the Ugly are my favourite Westerns, too. Rango and West and Soda are up there as well, despite being loving parodies of them.ReplyDelete
I personally love Westerns, no matter how problematic they are. It's the atmosphere for me. I personally find beauty in deserts and mountains. But each to their own.
I understand your point of view, though. Many of them are so superficial.